Eva Victor Agnes Ward Naomi Ackie Lydie Louis Cancelmi Preston Decker Kelly McCormack Natasha Lucas Hedges Gavin John Carroll Lynch Pete Hettienne Park Eleanor Winston E.R. Fightmaster Fran Cody Reiss Devin Jordan Mendoza Logan Anabel Graetz Professor Wilkinson Jonathan Myles The Man She Thought Was Decker Danny Diaz Student Liz Bishop Elizabeth David J. Curtis Judge Priscilla Manning Andrea Fuller Jesse Gabbard Hector Woguard Lucien Spelman Kevin Faber Celeste Oliva Sophie Conor Sweeney Jeremy Tierre Diaz Juror (uncredited) Jim Powers Shopper (uncredited)