David Howard Thornton Steamboat Willie Allison Pittel Selena Amy Schumacher Amber Jesse Posey Pete Jarlath Conroy Barry Brian Scolaro Captain Clark Kailey Hyman Cindi Rumi C. Jean-Louis Matteo Poonam Basu Jazzy Jarod Lindsey Moses Jesse Kove Lieutenant Diaz Jared Johnston Neil Tyler Posey Radio Operator Mike Brian Quinn Mitch McEverly Joe DeRosa Paul Sanguino Rachel Victoria Moore Jamie Peter Romano Officer Chris Anthony E. Williams Officer Martinez Charles Edwin Powell Borough President Molinari Tommy Bechtold TJ Tammi Cubilette Liz Michael Leavy Deckhand Bert Brunswick Jason Lockhart Cyclist Peter Ken Maharaj Albert Allyson Sereboff Aubrey Sarah Kopkin Ilsa Arindel Steven Della Salla Charlie DeLorenzo Gilbrando Acevedo Shirtless Cowboy