Addison Timlin Jami Veronica Cartwright Lillian Travis Tope Nick Anthony Anderson Lone Wolf Morales Joshua Leonard Deputy Foster Denis O'Hare Charles B. Pierce, Jr. Spencer Treat Clark Corey Gary Cole Chief Deputy Tillman Edward Herrmann Reverend Cartwright Ed Lauter Sheriff Underwood Arabella Field Dr. Kelly Wes Chatham Danny Morganna Bridgers Kendra Jaren Mitchell Johnny Kurt Krause Roy Lance E. Nichols Arkansas Mayor Geraldine Singer Texas Mayor Ricky Wayne Sheriff Rutland Colby Boothman-Shepard Paul Mason Bill Stinchcomb Mr. Holland Andrea Cohen Mrs. Holland Pam Dougherty Mrs. Scott Georges Wilson Older Farmer M. Serrano Soldier #1 Gerry May Newscaster Garrett Kruithof Ronald Murray Tammi Arender Newscaster #2 Gracie Whitton Young Jami Danielle Harris Townsperson #2 Charles B. Pierce Man in Diner Jeremy Ambler Gas Station Geezer Dodie Brown Townsperson