Luke Evans Nicky Billy Porter Gabriel Christopher Woodley Owen Andrew Rannells Matthew Robin Weigert Pam Kate Burton Maggie "Miggie" Phylicia Rashād Maya Isaac Powell Solo Michael Countryman Jim "Grumps" David Pittu Ian Cassandra Freeman Adele Gabby Beans Judith Liza J. Bennett Claire Francis Jue Jason Alfredo Narciso Lorenzo William DeMeritt Will Emily Donahoe Alexandra Ramsey Faragallah Judge Reynolds Gil Perez-Abraham Kevin Bryan Terrell Clark Jacob